Photo: iStockphoto
There's never a bad time for pie.
Whether you're picking up a slice to satisfy a late night craving for sweets or you need to bring a delicious desert to a dinner party on a time crunch, this Illinois pie shop never disappoints.
That's why customers far and wide cannot stop raving about their scrumptious assortment of confections. One pie in particular has captured the hearts (and stomachs) of eaters from all over the country.
According to a list compiled by Yelp, the best pie shop in Illinois is Hoosier Mama Pie Company in Chicago.
Per Yelp: "Yelpers love this Chicago favorite, which hand-makes pies daily. Yelp Elites especially love their chocolate cream pie, which they recommend ordering whole for special occasions. Be sure to pick up a quiche, too."
Here's what Yelp had to say about sourcing the data to discover the best pie spot in every state:
"This is an all-time list of the top pie spots in the U.S. according to Yelp Elites. We identified businesses in the cafe and bakery categories with pie keywords, then ranked those spots based on the volume and ratings of reviews given by Yelp Elite Squad members for each business. If a spot with more than one location was featured, the location with the higher rating was featured. All businesses were marked open on Yelp as of February 17, 2025. When available, all businesses on this list have a passing health score as of February 17, 2025."
For a continued list of the best places to order a pie in America, check out Yelp!